Haven't been on here in a bit...well I figured out the problem. I guess since I'm not running a nitrous filter, perhaps some crap from inside the bottle got in the solenoid in between the plunger and was causing it to stick open. I cleaned it out then tapped on the bottom of the housing with a hammer to reseat the plunger and presto the problem is solved. I now run two solenoids inline just in case one of them fails.